Her daughter died waiting over 1000 days for trans care. Now shes fighting to change the system. – LGBTQ Nation
LGBTQ

Her daughter died waiting over 1000 days for trans care. Now shes fighting to change the system. – LGBTQ Nation


Alice Litman knew who she was. She came out as trans to her family and friends in her teens. She did what she could to receive the care she needed. She was 20 when she died by suicide, having been on the NHS waitlist for a first appointment with a gender clinic for 1,023 days.

The last decade has seen a growing global web of misinformation about trans people, who they are, and how we can help them. That misinformation has been driven by and fomented anti-trans movements challenging trans inclusion in all walks of society and the access to healthcare that they can receive. In the UK, trans care has simply not been a priority, and these deaths are a direct result.

This is the story that Alice’s mother, Caroline Litman, tells in Her Name Is Alice, and the story that she continues to tell at marches, protests, and advocacy meetings. It is the story of Alice, of her family, and the services that failed them.

I was just furious at the patriarchy, and I [said to Alice], “why would you want to be a woman anyway.” Now, of course, I understand it’s not about wanting to be, but it’s those little things like that seem really big to me.

Caroline Litman

The Dangers of a Web of Misinformation

Her Name Is Alice is not the story of the perfectly accepting mother from the very beginning, but of the mother that so many trans people have: those who have been lied to about trans people as part of a manufactured panic and need to find their way to affirmation. It was apparent that Alice was struggling with something before she ever came out, but the idea that she was trans was something for Caroline’s friend to joke about, not something to be seriously considered.

When Alice came out to her family, Caroline went through a short period of denial, fueled by doubts and “reasonable concerns” pushed by trusted sources. When trying to understand and support her daughter, she unknowingly found herself reading a book by an anti-trans activist.

Alice/Carolina Litman
| Provided

“I was just really naïve,” Caroline says. “I was just like, ‘if it’s on Radio 4 and if it’s in The Guardian, it’s true because why would the newspapers lie to us?’” Putting trust in apparent experts, Caroline for a short time found herself arguing with her daughter over her own identity rather than providing full-throated affirmation from the off, as so many parents of trans people do. That period didn’t last, and it was just the start of a longer journey.

Later, Caroline writes in Her Name Is Alice that her daughter would go on to joke about that time. “You were such a transphobe.” What Caroline describes as a “profound but quite light-hearted conversation” was a reckoning in their journey, and a moment of love and pride as they reached greater understanding.

Caroline regrets the period when she wasn’t one hundred percent affirming. But it also helps her to understand the allure the anti-trans brigade has on other with their crusade of misinformation. She talks about the “perfect storm” that made it so easy to buy into the anti-trans narrative that tried to lead her down the wrong street for a time. “I was hitting menopause, I’d become really angry at the patriarchy, and all the stuff that was rising up in the press at exactly the same time: the [debunked] rapid onset gender dysphoria stuff from Lisa Littman.”

“I was just furious at the patriarchy, and I [said to Alice], ‘why would you want to be a woman anyway,’” she says. “Now, of course, I understand it’s not about wanting to be, but it’s those little things like that seem really big to me. Once you can get past that idea, that it’s not a want or a desire, it’s just a thing, it just completely changes your entire perspective.”

But while Caroline was able to reach that perspective, she also reflects with frustration that it was a perspective she had to come back to as an adult, an understanding she held before, in her youth, but had lost. She notes that as a teenager in the 1980s, she actually knew a trans woman in her community, and it wasn’t a big deal for young Caroline. “I was perfectly accepting of her 40 years ago, but not of Alice. What had changed? Well, what had changed was I just got older, and the media had done its work.”

Over time, Caroline fought her way out of that web of lies. Still, Jane, Caroline’s friend who had joked about trans identities, only became more entangled and challenged Caroline for being affirming of Alice, leading to Caroline breaking off contact entirely.

Jane, like a lot of women Caroline sees in the anti-trans movement, had been promised certain things would happen in their lives, that then didn’t, and had that same frustration with the patriarchy. The anti-trans movement was playing on that frustration, not to challenge the patriarchy, but to affirm the gender structures that uphold it. Through the online parenting forum Mumsnet, which has been a hub for anti-trans communities, Jane found a community that vindicated her beliefs while spreading (intentionally or unintentionally) misinformation, and Caroline suggests that’s a driving factor behind much of the anti-trans movement.

“I think [transphobia] gives them power.” The media certainly seem to reinforce that power. While Caroline has struggled to get attention on her message, she sees that “Sex Matters, or Bayswater Support Group, the parents who oppose their trans children, they get airtime, they get applauded, they get quotes in the papers, they get listened to in a Supreme Court ruling. And it gives them this kind of power: it makes them feel better, like we all want to feel powerful, we want to feel valued in that respect, that our opinion matters.”

Alice/Carolina Litman
| Provided

With some help, Jane eventually reevaluated things, apologized, and reconnected with Caroline, suggesting there is at least some hope of changing the minds of those who have swallowed the misinformation of the anti-trans movement. What finally changed Jane’s perspective was a simple presentation of facts: her son had confronted her about her views and recommended a video by Natalie Wynn of ContraPoints about JK Rowling. While Jane intended to just watch the first ten minutes to prove that it was wrong, she found herself watching the whole 90 minutes and reconsidering what she believed. In Her Name Is Alice, Caroline writes that Jane said: “Natalie Wynn – ContraPoints – was funny, clever and likable, and that she was quite pissed off that it was really hard to argue with anything she said.”

When confronted with a real trans person, Jane struggled to hold onto her prejudices, and in contrast, Caroline points to the way news and social media have talked about trans people for years, and how that has primed parents like her to not be affirming from the very beginning. “We were fed a lot of lies and bullsh*t, we shouldn’t have fallen for it, but we did do our absolute best to repair that as soon as soon as we could. A lot of us made mistakes that we wish we hadn’t made.”

But that misinformation, so pervasive across mainstream and social media, combined with how easy it is to fall into its web and stay there, has real-world impacts. The stories pushed by anti-trans activists and believed by everyone from social care workers to doctors are all part of what drives the failures of the systems that repeatedly let Alice down.

A World That Let Alice Down

When Alice died by suicide, it didn’t come out of nowhere within the systems that were supposed to protect her. There had been previous overdoses and, in theory, mental health follow-up. But both the mental care and gender-affirming care programs of the United Kingdom failed Alice.

That isn’t a simple assertion, but a connection supported by doctors who spoke at the inquest, and by the coroner for Alice’s case, Sarah Clarke, who filed a Prevention of Future Deaths Report. In the report, Clarke expressed concern over the lack of knowledge or training for those intended to provide mental health support to the trans community, the extensive delays in access to gender-affirming healthcare, and more. Since the report was filed in 2023, few efforts have been made to improve trans healthcare. Instead, elements of care for trans people have deteriorated or been fully banned while trans people themselves are excluded from public spaces with the updated EHRC guidance.

Before she was ever out to her family, Alice revealed her gender dysphoria to the NHS-funded Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHS) when struggling with suicidal ideation. Caroline later learned that the staff had dismissed it as irrelevant to her mental health struggle.

They know what they’re doing. They know that they’re harming these young trans people. They’re more afraid of another Keira Bell than they are of another Alice.

Caroline Litman

“They didn’t consider a trans identity could be part of the presenting problem,” says Caroline, who used to be an NHS psychiatrist. “And then when they did know that it was part of the presenting problem, they didn’t refer on to specialist services. That’s not what you do with a 16-year-old who’s been talking about suicidal ideation.”

Later, when Alice was seventeen, she talked to a therapist after an overdose. The nurse learned that Alice had experience in romantic relationships with people of multiple genders and responded biphobically, Caroline describes, accusing Alice of “poor lifestyle choices.” Six months later, in December, Alice took another overdose. The following February, she turned 18, graduating out of CAMHS care. Despite the recent overdose, they downgraded her risk assessment and declared that she didn’t need to be admitted to the adult mental health programs.

Alice/Carolina Litman
Alice Litman | Provided

When Clarke talks about the lack of knowledge or training, it is also buoyed by the misinformation and dismissal that the LGBTQ+ community faces, and that is especially virulent against trans people. Once Alice’s gender identity was understood, her treatment should have been relatively simple, but instead people who should have been caring for her kept trying to pass her on to someone else. “She didn’t have a severe and enduring mental health problem; her problem was that she was trans and she needed treatment for her transition. It’s just like everybody was playing it as a hot potato.”

Alice avoided signing up for the waitlist for the children’s gender services because the NHS waitlist was so long that she wouldn’t get an appointment before she was 18 and would have to start all over again on the adult gender clinic waitlist. Once she turned 18, she signed up for that waitlist. She was still on that waitlist when she died. Caroline says, “There was no help for her, she’s got this endless wait list, it’s like a prison cell, it’s like a torture chamber.”

While they tried to turn to private medicine for support, Caroline explains that by the time they were reaching out to Gender GP, run by Dr. Helen Webberly, demand for private services had exploded because of the NHS’s ever-expanding waitlists. As a result, Caroline says there were issues with care at Gender GP, including long delays at the start because of administrative errors, a lack of proper quality follow-up, and an inability to ensure Alice was on the right medication and responding well to it.

All of this was exacerbated by the story of one detransitioner and the misinformation about trans people and their own self-determination that spread from it. Shortly before Alice sought gender-affirming care, the Bell v. Tavistock case saw a woman, Keira Bell, challenge the Gender Identity Development Service (GIDS) over providing the care she requested between the ages of 17 and 22. Bell has continued to pressure the government not just to ban puberty blockers (which it has done) but to ban hormone therapy for anyone under 18.

These are the systems that failed Alice, and they continue to fail other trans people in the UK, young and old, every day. It doesn’t have to be that way, but Caroline sees a lack of desire for change.

“They know what they’re doing,” Caroline says. “They know that they’re harming these young trans people. They’re more afraid of another Keira Bell than they are of another Alice.”

Alice/Carolina Litman
| Provided

While not every trans person wants to go through a medical transition, gender dysphoria has been proven to be helped by gender-affirming care for those who want it. Simple access and shorter waitlists could have made a huge difference to Alice, as noted in the coroner’s Prevention of Future Deaths Report.

“If that is what you want, then it should be available to you,” says Caroline. Her experience as a psychiatrist helps her to see the flaw that the NHS is running into in pathologizing trans people and wanting to “cure” them rather than affirm them, just as so much misinformation and pushes for forms of conversion therapy suggest. “From my meeting with [then-Health Secretary] Wes Streeting and [Medical Director for NHS Specialized Services] James Palmer, it’s very, very clear to me that they see trans existence as problematic and undesirable, and that a cis presentation is the desirable norm, and what we should be aiming for in all cases.”

But as waitlists exceed 20 years, Caroline says there’s a simple solution: “embed [gender-affirming care] in primary care.” The current UK system requires endless referrals to specialized gender clinics with massive waitlists. What Caroline and other experts suggest is to empower General Practitioners (the UK equivalent of a PCP) to handle basic treatment, with only complex cases being referred to gender clinics: the same model that is used for most of UK healthcare. Under such a system, trans people could begin care in a matter of weeks rather than years, and the waitlists for clinics to address more complicated cases would dissolve.

“Dr. [James] Barrett at Alice’s inquest said that you could train a competent GP to treat gender dysphoria and hormone imbalances in a two-hour session,” Caroline explains. She also notes that any GP not comfortable providing gender-affirming care could abstain while those with the training took such appointments, the same process in place for abortion care.

Alice Litman
Alice Litman | Provided

In much of the UK, the waitlists continue to grow as trans people are put through endless repeat appointments at gender clinics rather than having GPs manage more aspects of the care. “They’re investing so much in ‘making sure’ and ‘being certain.’ It all goes back to this idea that patients don’t know themselves, and they’re making a mistake. I think it’s very simple to fix, but they don’t want to fix it.”

“There’s just no political will to do it, and there’s no medical will to do it, that’s the thing that I find really, really frustrating as an ex-medic: is that a medical profession has just rolled over and allowed government to dictate how they treat their patients, and I think if they did this about anything else, there would be an outcry, so why aren’t they outraged about trans care.”

Doctors and experts have offered solutions for gender-affirming care in the UK. The coroner has laid out the risk to life in the trans community if steps are not taken to improve the situation. While some inquests and Prevention of Future Death Reports have led to named laws to change things, for Alice nothing has changed, while misinformation and campaigns of hate against trans people continue to run rampant. Clearly the government and the higher-ups in the NHS have decided they’re okay with that cost.

Changing Hearts and Minds of the Cis Complacent

When Caroline first started writing, she was freshly dealing with grief and all the complexities that came with it. She has spent the intervening years campaigning, co-founding the advocacy group Transparent Action for parents of trans children, marching at Pride, and meeting with government ministers. And looking back at the book, and choices such as not naming JK Rowling as a major instigator in the campaign for anti-trans hate, she simply says, “I wasn’t as angry as I am now.”

That original writing process didn’t begin as a political statement, but as an exercise in self-determination. “It was only four months after Alice had died and I’d been quite mentally unwell in the interim period,” she says. The process helped her take back some agency in a world that had long tried to tell her she and her family were wrong. “I suddenly had this blank page. Nobody could stop me, and nobody could tell me that I wasn’t saying it right or doing it right. It kind of gave me my power back.”

Through that narrative, she also hopes that she can help other trans kids and their families avoid the same trauma and grief that the Litmans have experienced. “It was a human story that I was desperate to get across, because that’s what I think changes hearts and minds.”

Trans Pride 2023
Trans Pride 2023 | Provided

To an extent, that plan has worked, and Caroline has received supportive messages both from trans people and their parents who have been helped by it.

But, says Caroline, the book still isn’t reaching the people that she most wants to reach. “Because I think people will see it as a ‘trans book,’ and think ‘that doesn’t affect me, I’m not related to trans things.’ But I want it to stand on its own two feet as just a memoir about love and loss and grief.” For Caroline, the readers she wants to reach are those who might have a child that has come out as trans or might just have heard about trans people on the internet and thinks that they simply have “reasonable concerns” that have been bloated by the consumption of misinformation.

These are the people Caroline wants to call out for what she calls their “cis complacency” or “cis apathy.” “I talk about cis complacency a lot. Cis people find it very uncomfortable. They’re just not curious, they’re just not interested, and they just can’t see how it could affect their lives. It’s incredibly frustrating and disheartening, and I’m upset with myself that I had to have Alice, and then particularly lose her, in order to come to that understanding.”

Her Name Is Alice isn’t here to tell the trans community how bad things are for trans people: Caroline knows well that they are very aware of that. But it is to tell Alice’s story, highlight the importance of acceptance, and push complacent cis people to action.

“I just want them to wake up and smell the coffee,” Caroline says, frustration in her voice. “I want them to understand that they’re being lied to by the mainstream media. Not just about trans people, about literally everything.”

She sees the lies coming from the government, both before and after the appointment of the new prime minister, Andy Burnham. In response to trans protests and criticism, the government is eager to push press releases touting all they have done for LGBTQ+ people, and boasting that they are hosting the International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia, and Transphobia (IDAHOBIT) next year. These, Caroline says, are for the cis complacent, so they can feel good about what their government is doing.

But those releases come while so many of the government’s policies are hurting trans people. Whether it’s poor NHS care with untenable timelines, the EHRC guidance denying trans people access to public life, or the KCSIE guidance that is already in effect and torturing school children, the government’s policies are more likely to lead to another Alice than not. The government has the power to change all of these. Even in the face of the Supreme Court ruling, they can write new laws about how trans people should be included and identified. They can instruct the NHS to change how trans care is handled.

But, as Caroline says, “They don’t want to fix it.”

Alice and Carolina Litman
Alice and Carolina Litman | Provided

Editor’s note: This article mentions suicide. If you need to talk to someone now, call the Trans Lifeline at1-877-565-8860. It’s staffed by trans people, for trans people. The Trevor Project provides a safe, judgment-free place to talk for LGBTQ youth at1-866-488-7386. You can also call the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at1-800-273-8255.

Editor’s note: An earlier version of this article incorrectly stated that Carolina Litman tried to “cure” her daughter of being transgender. That was not correct. We apologize for the error.

Subscribe to theLGBTQ Nation newsletterand be the first to know about the latest headlines shaping LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.

Source link